I was reading an article on Yahoo! News about the recent ruling by the Supreme Court on whether or not eminent domain can apply to private projects that a municipality is wanting to encourage. My first outrage is that they ruled that using eminent domain to seize property for non-public use is constitutional. The worse shock though is how the justices ruled.
It turns out I am on the same side as Scalia, Thomas, Rehnquist, and O’Connor (*shudder*). All of the more liberal justices ruled in favor of the pro-business side. I just really don’t understand. I understand that eminent domain is an important tool for municipalities to use when doing large-scale projects such as roads, schools, and public utilities. There are times that the location of the project is paramount and the ability to get voluntary sales for all affected residents is just unrealistic. But I don’t know why one private owner should be ousted from their property in favor of another private owner.
Considering how unethical republicans are turning out to be in real estate recently, has the left side of the court opened up a new form of gerrymandering where you deem blue areas of a district to be blighted or just a convenient place for economic development by their corporate cronies? ![]()
Digg this!
June 23rd, 2005 at 5:48 pm
This Supreme Court thing is simply CRAZY wrong. I can’t believe it. Pay taxes on property you own, and its taken away. Compensation hasn’t been confirmed, and you know if there is any, its for far less than market value. And for what? So someone can generate more tax dollars.
I lean to the right, you lean to the left. However one thing I think we can both agree to is that both sides are at each other’s throats far too often to pay attention to important matters, combined they are not serving the people very well.
Its the kind of childish battling you see on a playground.
June 25th, 2005 at 10:52 pm
I’ve read horror stories about this kind of thing being put into action. Especially when city-approved appraisals set “fair” price. One especially hair-raising story was about some New Jersey beachfront housing owned by people for decades that was taken from them for pennies on the dollar and sold for condo development. It really does make me want to poke my eyes out.
We’re going to be paying for the setbacks caused by the current climate in this country for decades.
June 25th, 2005 at 11:11 pm
Left is the new right.
Welcome to the dark side.
December 2nd, 2007 at 2:59 am
Real Estate Guide
I couldn’t understand some parts of this article, but it sounds interesting